.png?width=180&height=65&name=Untitled%20design%20(29).png "Untitled design (29)")
Choosing an insurance agent is a big decision. This person will help protect your home, car, and finances, so you want to make sure they're up to the task. Many people simply go with the first agent they find or a company with a catchy jingle, but it pays to do a little interviewing of your own. Before you start searching online for the best insurance agent near me, make sure you have a list of questions ready. Asking the right questions will help you figure out if an agent is knowledgeable, trustworthy, and a good fit for your needs.
Below are five crucial questions to ask any prospective insurance agent before you decide to work with them. These questions will not only give you insight into the agent’s capabilities and approach, but also help you compare different agents on the same criteria. Remember, you are hiring them to handle your insurance, so it’s okay to dig a bit!
1. Are you an independent or captive insurance agent?
Why to ask: This is one of the first things you should find out, because it affects the options you'll receive. An independent insurance agent works with multiple insurance companies, while a captive agent represents just one insurer. If the agent is independent, they can shop around and provide quotes from a variety of insurers. This means you’ll likely see several coverage options and price points. On the other hand, if the agent is captive (for example, an agent who only sells policies for State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, etc.), they will only offer you that company’s products.
What to listen for: There’s nothing wrong with either type, but an independent agent can usually offer more flexibility. If you hear that an agent can get quotes from "dozens of carriers" or "multiple top insurance companies," that's a sign you're dealing with an independent agent who can do comparison shopping for you. If they say they only represent one company, then you know all your quotes will come from that single insurer. Knowing this upfront helps set your expectations. If you’re looking for one-stop convenience to compare many insurers at once, an independent agent is likely the way to go. If you already favor a particular insurance company and just want a local representative for that insurer, a captive agent can suffice. The key is to know what you're getting.
2. How do you determine my insurance needs?
Why to ask: A great insurance agent doesn’t just plug your information into a computer and hand you a generic quote. They should take time to understand your situation and recommend coverage that truly fits. By asking this question, you’re basically saying: "How will you figure out what coverage is right for me?" This gives the agent a chance to explain their process.
What to listen for: Look for an agent who mentions doing a needs analysis or asking you detailed questions about your home, car, drivers, and any special circumstances. For example, they might say they’ll review the value of your home and possessions to recommend the right level of homeowners coverage, or ask about your driving habits and who uses your vehicles to tailor your auto policy. The agent might bring up topics like umbrella insurance if you have a lot of assets, or flood insurance if you live in a flood-prone area. This shows they are thinking beyond just the basics. Be cautious if an agent seems to offer a quote or policy without learning much about you — that could be a red flag that they are not thorough. You want someone who will customize your coverage, not take a one-size-fits-all approach.
3. Can I save money through discounts or bundling?
Why to ask: Insurance can be expensive, so you’ll want to know how the agent will help you get the best value. Most insurance companies offer a variety of discounts, and independent agents can also check different carriers for better rates. Bundling (insuring your home and auto with the same company) is one of the most common discounts — often called a multi-policy discount. By asking this question, you’re prompting the agent to discuss ways to lower your premium.
What to listen for: A good agent will gladly discuss discounts and cost-saving strategies. They might mention things like bundling your home and auto insurance together, safe driver discounts, good student discounts for young drivers, home security system discounts, claim-free discounts, and so on. They should also be willing to periodically re-shop your rates. For example, an independent agent might say, "If your premium goes up at renewal, I can compare rates again among our other insurance partners to make sure you're still getting a competitive deal." This is exactly what you want to hear.
Essentially, you want an agent who is proactive about saving you money without sacrificing coverage. If an agent brushes off the question or gives an unclear answer, you might end up paying more than you need to.
4. What happens if I have to file a claim?
Why to ask: How an agent assists you after you become a customer is just as important as the initial sale. Filing an insurance claim – whether it’s for a car accident or damage to your home – can be a stressful experience. An agent’s role in the claims process can vary. Some agents will help guide you through it step by step, while others might direct you to call the company’s 1-800 claims number and step back. By asking this question, you set the expectation that you value support when things go wrong.
What to listen for: Ideally, the agent will explain that they are there to help you before, during, and after a claim. For instance, they might say, "If you have a claim, you can call me directly and I’ll walk you through the next steps," or "Our office will help you file the claim and follow up with the company to make sure everything is handled properly." This indicates excellent customer service. They may also describe the claims process in general – like how long it usually takes, or whether you can get a local adjuster. The key is that you feel confident you wouldn’t be left on your own in a crisis.
If instead the agent just says, "Oh, you’d just call the 1-800 number and they’ll take care of it," without any hint of personal help, you might end up essentially dealing with a faceless company when a claim happens. Since one of the big advantages of having an agent is personalized service, make sure you choose someone who will be there for you when you need them.
5. How long have you been an insurance agent?
Why to ask: Experience isn’t everything, but it’s certainly reassuring. By asking about an agent’s background, you can get a sense of their expertise. This question might also invite them to share any special qualifications or licenses. For example, they could mention, "I’ve been in the insurance business for 15 years," or "I started out working for a big insurance company and now I’m an independent agent." Some might note designations like CPCU or CIC, which are advanced certifications in insurance knowledge. The goal here isn’t to disqualify newer agents — even a newer agent can be great if they have proper training and support — but it helps to know who you’re dealing with.
What to listen for: There’s no perfect answer, but generally, more experience means they've handled a wider array of scenarios. If an agent has, say, a decade or more of experience, they’ve likely helped clients through numerous claims, coverage changes, and unique situations. They might have a long list of satisfied clients or a strong reputation in the community. If they’re relatively new, listen for indicators of professionalism and support, such as mentioning a mentor or that they’re part of a knowledgeable team.
The agent’s willingness to answer this question openly is also important — it shows transparency. In addition, you can ask for references or check online reviews regardless of experience level. A trustworthy agent usually has positive feedback from other customers.
Final Thoughts
Your insurance agent will be your go-to resource when life throws curveballs – from fender benders to house fires and everything in between. Taking the time to ask these questions now will pay off with better service and peace of mind later. Don’t be shy about being thorough; a quality agent will respect that you’re making an informed choice.
As you talk to potential agents, compare their answers. Did one agent stand out in how they explained things or the level of service they promise? Those are signs you’ve found someone who truly puts customers first. By vetting agents with these questions, you're well on your way to finding an insurance advisor who will have your back.
And remember, you don’t have to do it all alone. We can help simplify the search. If you’re shopping for home or auto insurance, we’ll connect you with a trusted local agent from our national network.
