The Coffee Shop Test: Would You Hire Your Agency?

  • June 9, 2026

The Coffee Shop Test: Would You Hire Your Agency?

Imagine this.

You're sitting in a coffee shop.

Two people at the next table are discussing insurance.

One of them asks:

"Do you know a good agency?"

Now here's the challenge.

Based on the experience your clients currently receive...

Would someone confidently recommend you?

Or would they hesitate?


Most Agencies Think About Sales

Very few think about recommendation.

They're different.

Sales happens once.

Recommendations happen repeatedly.


What Creates Recommendations?

Not fancy branding.

Not slogans.

Not giveaways.

People recommend agencies because of experiences.


They Answered When Nobody Else Did

That's memorable.


They Explained Something Clearly

That's memorable.


They Solved A Problem Quickly

That's memorable.


They Reduced Stress

That's memorable.


The Question Every Agency Should Ask

If someone described your agency to a friend today...

What would they say?

Would it sound like:

"They saved me money."

Or:

"They made my life easier."

One creates transactions.

The other creates loyalty.


The Reality

The strongest agencies aren't necessarily the most visible.

They're the most talked about.

And there is a difference.


Bottom Line

Every interaction either increases or decreases the odds of a recommendation.

The agencies growing through referrals aren't getting lucky.

They're creating experiences people want to talk about.

Related Articles

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

Summer Is Closer Than You Think. Here’s What Agencies Should Be Preparing For Now

May 26, 2026
Summer Is Closer Than You Think. Here’s What Agencies Should Be Preparing For Now A lot of agencies wait too long to...

Your Agency Has a Reputation. The Question Is: Did You Build It on Purpose?

June 16, 2026
Your Agency Has a Reputation. The Question Is: Did You Build It on Purpose? Every agency has a reputation.

The Most Dangerous Words in an Insurance Agency: “We’ve Always Done It This Way”

June 2, 2026
The Most Dangerous Words in an Insurance Agency: “We’ve Always Done It This Way” Every agency has heard it.